Revista de Ciencias Biológicas y de la Salud http://biotecnia.unison.mx
Universidad de Sonora
ISSN: 1665-1456
1 Benemérita Universidad Autónoma de Puebla, Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas y Pecuarias, Avenida Universidad 59, Primera. San Juan Acateno, Teziutlán, Puebla, México.
Tierra de diatomea y Bauveria bassiana en matrices de alcohol polivinilico, un efecto combinado para el control de Pieris brassicae
Cabbage larvae (Pieris brassicae, Lepidoptera: Pieridae) are an important pest in organic farming; therefore, biological pest control alternatives are being sought. The effect of Beauveria bassiana (Bb) combined with diatomaceous earth (DE) in a polyvinyl alcohol flask (Bbl), as well as the combination between them (Bb+DE, BbI+DE) on P. brassicae and Galleria mellonella larvae inoculated by aspersion or immersion was evaluated. Prior to the experiment, the viability of B. bassiana was assessed and one of three commercial brands of diato- maceous earth was selected based on the shape and dama- ge caused to G. mellonella. Radial shapes with and without edges were more common in the diatomaceous earth types, but these did not define efficacy on cuticle damage. The re- sult showed that the Bb+DE treatment had greater damage, followed by the Bbl+DE treatment applied by aspersion. The highest mortality in G.mellonella was 70.1 % with Bb at 120 h after sprinkled, while in P. brassicae, mortality reached 42.1 % with Bbl+DE; thus, it is important to highlight the importance of the inoculation method and larvae types used when effec- tiveness bio-trials are performed.
Keywords: Polyvinyl alcohol, Aspersion, B. bassiana, Morta- lity, Plague.
La larva de la col (Pieris brassicae, Lepidóptera: Pieridae), es una plaga importante en la agricultura orgánica, por lo que se buscan alternativas para su control. En este estudio, se eva- luó el efecto de Beauveria bassiana sola (Bb) y combinada con tierra de diatomea (TD) en matrices de alcohol polivinílico (BbI), así como la combinación entre estos (Bb+TD, BbI+TD) en larvas de P. brassicae y Galleria mellonella inoculadas por aspersión y por inmersión. Previo al experimento, se evaluó la viabilidad de B. bassiana, y seleccionó una de tres marcas comerciales de tierra de acuerdo con su forma y daño pro- vocado en G. mellonella, donde las formas radiales con y sin borde fueron mas frecuentes en los tipos de tierra, sin embar- go, estas no definieron la eficacia en daño de cutícula. El re- sultado mostró que el tratamiento Bb+TD tuvo mayor daño, seguido del tratamiento BbI+TD aplicados por aspersión. La mortalidad más alta en G. mellonella fue 70.1 % con Bb a las 120 h después de aperjado, mientras que en P. brassicae la mortalidad alcanzó 42.1 % con BbI+TD, por lo que hay que destacar la importancia del método de inoculación y el tipo
*Autor para correspondencia: C. Hernández Domínguez Correo-e: carmela.hernandezd@correo.buap.mx Recibido: August 2, 2023
Aceptado: April 3, 2024
Publicado: May 13, 2024
de larva utilizada al realizar bioensayos de efectividad. Palabras clave: Alcohol polivinílico 1, Aspersión, B. bassiana 2, mortalidad 3, plaga.
Cabbage is one of the most relevant crops in the Central America and Caribbean zones, also with great economic importance since it is one of the cruciferous vegetables of greatest consumption (Mujica et al., 2009); there is an annual production of 204 thousand tons only in Mexico (SIAP, 2019). Although it is susceptible to damage by Lepidoptera species,
P. brassicae stands out, this plague is capable of devouring a great number of leaves, leading to important production losses (Abbas et al., 2021).
The last decade has given special importance to eco- logical soil handling and nutrition, recognizing the organic production in Latin America, Asia, and European countries, due to its contribution to sustainable development (Schwen- tesius and Gómez, 2015; Willer, 2021) and, with the chemical products elimination, keeping the soil quality and fertility. On the other hand, the excessive use of pesticides harms the environment, indirectly contributing to the elimination of the natural enemies of plagues (Del Puerto et al., 2014; Cas- tro et al., 2022). Recently, special attention has been given to the use of entomopathogenic microorganisms, which cause lethal infection of pests and have been shown to have signi- ficant broad-spectrum effects on pest species that damage crops (Bacca and Lagos, 2014; Pacheco et al., 2019). B. bassiana species are entomopathogenic fungi with great potential in diverse insect plague management, due to the biosynthesis of diverse cyclopeptide compounds, that act against fungal virulence (Wang, 2017). However, when applied in field conditions, entomopathogen microorganisms are affected by several factors, such as temperature, humidity, and solar radiation. Therefore, they need to be formulated in a method that enhances their efficacy, and to achieve this, the fungi are retained in immobilization matrices that protect the spores from environmental threats, thereby extending their shelf life when applied in the field (Azamar-Jiménez, 2018; Litwin et al., 2020).
On the other hand, the use of additives in biological control products is of great importance as it increases the efficacy of the formulations; one of these products is diato- maceous earth, which consists of crystalized algae microfos-
Volume XXVI
DOI: 10.18633/biotecnia.v26.2124
sils that cause injuries in the insect body (Losic and Korunic, 2018; Bachrouch et al., 2022). However, little is known about the combined effect of diatomaceous earth with B. bassiana matrices for plague control. Therefore, the aim of this re- search was to evaluate the effect of diatomaceous earth in combination with the entomopathogenic fungi B. bassiana immobilized in polyvinyl alcohol matrices, as a biological agent against P. brassicae in cabbage crops.
B. bassiana OM839761
The strain was obtained from the collection of the Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas y Pecuarias of the Benemérita Univer- sidad Autónoma de Puebla. Sample was defrosted and 100 µL were inoculated in solid Agar Dextrose Sabouraud (ADS) medium, and then incubated at 32 °C± 2 for 5 d, and the grown mycelium was collected with the aid of a spatula to create the treatments.
Ninety G. mellonella larvae were used as reference insects, obtained from the Escuela Tecnológica Superior of Zacapoa- xtla; also, 90 P. brassicae larvae were obtained from a cabbage crop naturally infested, located at the Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas y Pecuarias.
Food grade quality, micronized, and organic Diatomaceous earth was acquired from GOSA©, Echinocactus©, and Lom- briz MX© brands, and purchased from different commercial stores.
To select the diatomaceous earth, the efficacy of three brands was evaluated and three 600 mL solutions were prepared at concentrations of 0.01 g/mL, 0.002 g/mL, and 0.001 g/mL. With a Neubauer camera in a Leyca DM750 compound mi- croscope the percentage of algal shell shapes present in each sample was quantified; then, 10 G. mellonella larvae in the last instar were added and manually shaken for 10 seconds at each concentration according to Vargas-Flores (2003). Finally, were placed over pieces of sterile moist paper towels contained in 140 x 20 mm capacity Petri dishes.
After 48 h of inoculation, a 5 mm2 incision was made on the dorsal part of the larval skin. The incision was then cleaned of fat residues and observed under the microscope to de- termine the percentage of spots (damage) over the cuticle. This data was subsequently correlated with the percentage of shell shapes.
For the prepration of the treatment one (Bb) which consisted of B. bassiana 1 x 106 conidia/mL, conidia were collected from a Petri dish containing 5-day-old B. bassiana and added to 600 mL sterile distilled water to a concentration of 1 x 106 conidia per mL. The preparation of treatment two (DE) consisted of diatomaceous earth 10 mg/mL in 600 mL sterile distilled wa- ter, 6 g of GOSA diatomaceous earth were added to obtain a concentration of 0.01 g/mL, and the mixture was vortexed with a Hermann® Vortex until a homogenized mixture was obtained. While for treatment three (Bbl), which was Immo- bilized B. bassiana 2% and 12 g of GOLDEN BELL® polyvinyl alcohol, was weighed and added to 600 mL of sterile distilled water contained in a 1 L flask, the solution was heated until the alcohol was dissolved and sterilized in an autoclave at 121 °C for 15 min; once the solution was cold, B. bassiana co- nidia from a Petri dish were added and incubated for 5 days until a concentration of 1x106 conidia per mL was obtained, according to the methodology described by Barranco-Flori- do et al. (2009). For treatment four (Bb+DE), which consisted of B. bassiana 1 x 106 conidia/mL + diatomaceous earth 10 mg/mL, the combination of treatment one and treatment two was made, it was formulated as a 600 mL solution 1:1 contained in a 1L flask. Treatment five (Bbl+DE) consisted of immobilized B. bassiana 2 % + diatomaceous earth 10 mg/ mL, a combination of treatment two and treatment three was formulated and a 600 mL solution 1:1 was contained in a 1L flask. Finally for the treatment six (Witness) 600 mL of sterile distilled water were used. The viability was determined in SDA following the methodology by Berlanga-Padilla and Hernández-Velázquez (2002) for all treatments that included conidia. In 5 different spots of a Petri dish (100 x 15 mm), a circle was marked with SDA agar, over which 2 µL of a 1 x 107 conidia/mL suspension was added, then coverslips were placed and after 24 h, the total number of conidia germinat- ed in each spot was observed and registered using a Leyca DM750 microscope.
The G. mellonella and P. brassicae with B. bassiana larvae inoculation process consisted of two events: first, 60 last in- star G. mellonella larvae were simultaneously placed on moist sterile paper towels and 140 x 20 mm Petri dishes and inoc- ulated by aspersion with 3 L capacity TRUPER® sprinkler at 38 PSI for each treatment, plus 30 larvae with the same charac- teristics inoculated by immersion. For the second event, 90 last instar P. brassicae larvae were collected from a naturally infested cabbage crop and treatments were applied similarly to the G. mellonella larvae without immersion applications.
Damage percentage was evaluated at 24, 48, 72 and 120 h after inoculation, for this, the damage on the larvae cuticle was observed in a Leyca brand stereoscope. No damage in P. brasicae and G. mellonella, was observed, but cuticle melani- zation appeared.
Mortality was evaluated at 24, 48, 72 and 120 hours after inoculation, values calculated and adjusted using the correc- ted mortality percentage formula (Abbott, 1925) to ensure normality and homogeneity of variances, then the data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA).
SAS version 9.0 for Windows 2008 was used with prior confir- mation of normal data distribution. In the evaluation of the three diatomaceous earth brands, a factorial design was used to know the effect, with three simultaneous concentrations and a Tukey’s multiple comparison test with α = 0.05 to select the best one. In G. mellonella, an evaluation of the variability among treatments in cuticle damage and larval mortality was determined by a Tukey’s multiple comparison test with α = 0.05, and the relationship was determined by a Pearson’s correlation coefficient between cuticle damage and the per- centage of shapes found in each treatment. For the second evaluation with P. brassicae, it was determined if there was a significant variance in the percentage of dead larvae, and the best treatment was determined with a Tukey’s mean comparison with α = 0.05.
In addition, data analysis did not show significant differences between brands and diatomaceous earth-shell concentrations. Nevertheless, the Tukey test (P ≤ 0.05) showed a greater amount of diatom shell shapes in the Echinocactus brand at 0.01 g/mL concentration, followed by the Gosa brand at 0.01 g/mL concentration, while the brand with the lower diatom shell shapes was Lombriz at 0.0001 g/ mL concentration (Figure 2). It was also observed that as the particle concentration increases, the amount of shell shapes increases depending on the brand, as the concentration with the highest mean microalgae shell shape for all brands was
0.01 g/mL concentration, while the lowest mean was 0.001 g/ mL concentration.
The spots as a sign of damage by diatomaceous earth were found in greater amounts under the larvae abdomen. GOSA brand at 0.01 concentration caused 100 % of the spots on the cuticle of G. mellonella larvae, followed by Echinocactus brand at the same concentration with 77 %, while Lombriz- MX grand at 0.001 g/mL concentration caused 44 % of the damage (Table 1).
Nevertheless, the correlation analysis between the number of spots observed by microscope field and the percentage of shell shapes present per treatment, showed a weak positive correlation (0.768) between variables, with a determination coefficient of R2 = 0.59 (Figure 3).
G. mellonella and P. brassicae with B. bassiana larvae ino- culation and treatments effectiveness
Statistical differences were found between treatments based on the number of spots found on G. mellonella (P ≤ 0.01) (Figure 4). Bb+DE was the best treatment with a value of 7.22 spots found over the G. mellonella cuticle, followed by the polyvinyl alcohol immobilized B. bassiana treatment and the diatomaceous earth combination (Bbl+DE), while the minimum effective treatment was the TDS with a value of
4.5
4
Frequency mean
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
RB RSB V E
Diatomaceous earth shapes
Figura 1. Frecuencia de formas de caparazones encontradas en tierra de diatomea. Medias con la misma letra no son significativamente diferentes (P ≤ 0.05). Radial con bordo (RB), Forma radial sin bordo (RSB), Forma de varilla (V), Forma de elipse (E).
a
b
b
c
Figure 1. Frequency of shell shapes found in dia- tomaceous earth. Means with the same letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05). Radial with rim (RB), radial shape without rim (RSB), rod shape (V), ellipse shape (E).
a
a
b
Frequency means of shapes
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
GOSA Echinocactus Lombriz MX
Diatomaceous earth brands
Figura 2. Número de formas de caparazones de algas de acuerdo con la maraca de tierra de diatomea. Medias con la misma letra no son significativamente diferentes.
Figure 2. Number of shell shapes according to the brand of diatomaceous earth. Means with the same letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05).
Tabla 1. Porcentaje de daño sobre la cutícula de G. mellonella a 120 h.
Table 1. Percentage of damage on the G. mellonella cuticle at 120 h
Commercial brand | Concentration (g/mL) | ||
0.01 | 0.002 | 0.001 | |
GOSA© | 100% | 77% | 66% |
Echinocactus© | 77% | 75% | 55% |
Lombriz MX© | 50% | 55% | 44% |
Percentage of spots per microscope field
10
8.00
7.00
Spots' mean frequency
6.00
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
a
ab
ab
ab
b
b
DES DE Bb + DES Bb + DE BbI + DES BbI + DE
Treatments
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 1 2 3 4
Number of diatomaceous earth shapes
Figura 3. Correlación entre el número de formas de caparazones de algas entre marcas de tierra de diatomea y el porcentaje de manchas sobre la cutí- cula de G. mellonella cuticle. y = 1.8709x + 1.5705, R² = 0.5909.
Figure 3. Correlation between the number of shell shapes in three brands of
diatomaceous earth and the percentage of spots on the G. mellonella cuticle. y = 1.8709x + 1.5705, R² = 0.5909.
4.56. Also, a significant difference was observed between the counting hours for the number of spots present (P ≤ 0.0001), and according to the comparison of Tukey means, the time that showed the greatest number of spots was at 72 h, as opposed to 24 and 48 h. It is worth mentioning that no spots were observed on P. brassicae.
Figura 4. Media de frecuencia de número de manchas provocadas por el daño del tratamiento. Tratamientos a los cuales se les agrega una S fueron aplicados por el método de inmersión, mientras que los que no tienen S fue- ron aplicados por el método de aspersión. Medias con la misma letra no son significativamente diferentes (P ≤ 0.05).
Figure 4. Mean frequency of spots caused by treatment damage. To speci- fy that the treatments were applied by immersion, the letter S was added to the treatment key, otherwise, the treatments were applied by spraying. Means with the same letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05).
The treatment that caused the greatest mortality in G. mellonella was the solution of conidia in distilled water (Bb) through immersion application with 80 %, which was statistically different from the witness that registered 0 %, while the Bbl+DE treatment reached 40 % through the same application, although when changing the application method, this last treatment increased the larval mortality up to 60 %; at the same time, the best treatment was Bb through immersion method, but when the aspersion method was used, mortality decreased by 10 % (Figure 5).
The observations with G. mellonella in the aspersion application showed that the most effective treatment in P. brassicae was the Bbl+DE with a mortality percentage of 42
90%
G.mellonella mortality (%)
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Bb DE BbI Bb + DE BbI + DE Witness
Treatmens
Moreover, regarding the results observed in the diffe- rent brands of diatomaceous earth and at different concen- trations, Arnaud et al. (2005) showed similar results when applying diatomaceous earth formulations at different con- centrations, confirming that the higher the concentration, the greater the damage caused in the insect.
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
40%
40%
20%
10%
0%
0% 0%
The correlation analysis between G. mellonella spots over the cuticle and the number of shapes present in the dia- tomaceous earth brand, suggests that the level of damage could also be related to other factors such as quality and pu- rity (Reka et al., 2021), as declared by Alves et al. (2017) that at
Figura 5. Porcentaje de mortalidad por efecto de los tratamientos en larvas de G. mellonella por diferentes métodos de inoculación. Tratamiento por in- mersión (), tratamiento por aspersión (). B. bassiana 1x10 6 conidia/mL (Bb), tierra de diatomea 1 mg/mL (TD), B. bassiana inmovilizada 6 % (BbI), B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidias/mL + tierra de diatomea 1 mg/ mL (Bb+TD).
Figure 5. Percentage of mortality due to the effect of the treatments on G.
mellonella worm by different inoculation methods. Immersion treatment (), spray treatment (). B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidia/mL (Bb), diatomaceous earth 1 mg/mL (DE), immobilized B. bassiana 6 % (BbI), B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidia/mL + diatomaceous earth 1 mg/ mL (Bb+DE).
%, while the same treatment used in G. mellonella showed 18 % more mortality. On the other hand, the less effective treatment in both species was Bb+DE (Figure 6).
70%
60%
50%
40%
42%
42%
34%
25%
20%
17%
16%
0%
80%
70%
Mortality (%)
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Bb DE BbI Bb+DE BbI+DE Witness
Treatments
Figura 6. Mortalidad de G. mellonella y P. brassicae a 120h después de la inoculación por el método de aspersión. G. mellonella (),P. brassicae ().
B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidia/mL (Bb), tierra de diatomacea 1 mg/mL (TD), B. bassiana inmovilizada en alcohol polivinilico 6 % (BbI), B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidias/mL + tierra de diatomea 1 mg/ mL (Bb+TD).
Figure 6. Mortality of G. mellonella and P. brassicae at 120h after inoculation
by spray method. G. mellonella (), P. brassicae (). B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 co- nidia/mL (Bb), diatomaceous earth 1 mg/mL (DE), immobilized B. bassiana 6% (BbI), B. bassiana 1 x 10 6 conidia/mL + diatomaceous earth 1 mg/ mL (Bb+DE).
According to the microalgae shell shapes from the diatoma- ceous earth brands, Colín-Garcia et al. (2013) indicate that shell patterns are specific and genetically determined, so there is a great variety of shapes in the diatomaceous earth. Hence, there will be greater or lesser effectiveness. Also, Na- trass et al. (2015) mentioned that the shape variability shown in the diatomaceous earth also depends on the extraction site.
greater quality and purity, the effectiveness of diatomaceous earth is greater; in this case, the less pure earth was the one that caused less damage. Although it is not excluded that the shape of particles confirming the diatomaceous earth is related to the damage to the insect cuticule, since it has been observed that the shells with acute shape cause greater da- mage (Zeni et al., 2021; Korunic, 2013), in this study there was a low presence of acute shapes and a greater predominance of radial shapes that could have interfered with the damage percentage; in this regard, Korunic (1998) stated that the effectiveness is related to the contact established between the radial particle surface and the insect cuticule; the more uniform the surface, the greater will be the cuticle adhesion.
According to the results, the damage effectiveness of the treatments over the G. mellonella larvae cuticle showed a lower effect with the treatment with diatomaceous earth and B. bassiana immobilized in polyvinyl alcohol; Liauw et al. (2020) and Angeli et al. (2022) mention that polyvinyl alcohol prevents contact between the spore surface and the diato- maceous earth particles, avoiding its function over the insect cuticle when a liquid is applied. Although these authors also mention that dry encapsulation has shown good results in adhesion and conidia retention on surfaces, these formula- tions promote the abrasive action of the diatomaceous earth particles without being trapped in the liquid formulations. Thus, the treatment with the best results was B. bassiana + diatomaceous earth applied by aspersion. According to Wakil et al. (2021) and Zeni et al. (2021), in these applications, the particles have a greater possibility to touch the insect, and those that are above the surfaces, can be picked up more easily by the insect, unlike the immersion application where only the particles adhered to the insect body will act; besides in immersion applications, there is less time for the particles to adhere to larvae cuticle when submerged in and out of the solution very quickly (Abdou et al., 2022), the time is essential to obtain better results. For example, in this study the time showing greater number of spots was at 72 h, although the damage in the insect cuticule also depends on the species, since in this case there were no spots on P. brassicae cuticule.
The mortality effectiveness of water-diluted B. bassiana has been well documented, unlike for spores covered with polyvinyl alcohol (Ozdemir et al., 2020) both in G. mellonella and P. brassicae, although Nazzaro et al. (2012) reported the advantages of polyvinyl alcohol used as an alternative co- vering material, such as fungal conidia, in which it prolongs
its useful life (Wenzel et al., 2017). Although in this case, the treatment with immobilized B. bassiana in polyvinyl alcohol flasks along with diatomaceous earth (T5) did not cause the expected efficacy when applied by immersion, it has to be considered that the efficacy also depends on the formulation applied. Therefore, additional tests are suggested with B. bassiana spores covered with polyvinyl alcohol powder for- mulated and applied to G. mellonella and P. brassicae.
The results also showed that, in addition to obtaining a different effect with the treatment and application, the larval mortality effectiveness is related to the larval species suscep- tibility that receives the treatment as mentioned by Korunic (1998; 2013), with the possible retention of diatomaceous earth particles and B. bassiana spores inside the polyvinyl alcohol flask which does not allow them to act in applications by immersion and aspersion. Although, the lack of previous studies on the effectiveness of B. bassiana and immobilized diatomaceous earth in polyvinyl alcohol to reinforce these results make it difficult to draw convincing conclusions.
In this study, the amount and shape of the algal shells present in the diatomaceous earth was observed to cause damage to the G. mellonella cuticle; therefore, when using high-purity diatomaceous earth products, efficacy is assured. Also, when immobilizing B. bassiana conidia in polyvinyl al- cohol vials with diatomaceous earth particles, direct contact of both with the surfaces where they are applied should be avoided, since the effect is less than that observed when applying only B. bassiana conidia diluted in water. The above could be show with scanning microscope images, however, there was the limitation of not having the equipment. In adi- tion, it is necessary to work on studies with polyvinyl alcohol powder formulations covering the conidia, leaving the diato- maceous earth particles free to exert their abrasive action on the insect cuticle. It is also suggested to carry out an additio- nal study with at least two species of insects to better detect the effect of the treatments and to obtain reliable results, and decide if the application of these treatments can be made by aspersion or by immersion, since a high concentration of alcohol dissolved in water could limit the aspersion success.
To the Consejo Nacional de Humanidades, Ciencia and Tecnología (CONAHCyT) for the financial support granted to the first author during the graduate studies in the Potential Phyto-Genetic Agricultural Resources Master’s Degree.
The authors declare that there is a non-existing conflict of interest.
Abbas, W., Javed, N., Haq, I. U., and Ahmed, S. 2021. Pathogenicity of entomopathogenic nematodes against cabbage butterfly (Pieris brassicae) Linnaeus (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) in laboratory conditions. International Journal of Tropical Insect Science. 41(1): 525-531.
Abbott, W. S. 1925. A method of computing the effectiveness of an insecticide. Journal of Economic Entomology. 18 (2): 265-267.
Abdou, M. A., Ahmed, S. S., and Zyaan, O. H. 2022. Efficacy of two entomopathogenic fungi in combination with diatomaceous earth against Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences. A, Entomology. 15(4): 155-169.
Alves, L. F., Martins, C., Nardelli, M., and Alves, V. 2017. In vitro assay and morphological characterization of a new product based on diatomaceous earth for lesser mealworm control in poultry houses. Arquivos Do Instituto Biológico. 84: 1-6, e0782015.
Angeli, L. F., Pinto, D. G., and Barbosa, R. 2022. Liquid preparation of diatomaceous earth against the lesser mealworm, Alphitobius diaperinus (Panzer, 1797) (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae). Arquivos Do Instituto Biológico, 89: 1-9, e00032022.
Arnaud, L., Tran Thi Lan, H., Brostaux, Y., and Haubruge, E. 2005. Efficacy of diatomaceous earth formulations admixed with grain against populations of Tribolium castaneum. Journal of Stored Products Research, 41(2): 121-130.
Azamar-Jiménez, I. J. 2018. Encapsulación de Beauveria bassiana en biomateriales a base de polímeros. Universidad del papaloapan. Available in: https://www.unpa.edu.mx/ tesis_Tux/tesis_digitales/maestria_biotecnologia/MB33-_ AZAMAR_JIMENEZ_IVONNE_JANETH.pdf
Bacca, T., and Lagos, T. C. 2014. Efecto de Beauveria bassiana y del entomonematodo Steinernema sp. sobre larvas de Galleria mellonella. Boletín Científico. Centro de Museos. Museo de Historia Natural, 18(1): 247-258.
Bachrouch, O., Nefzi, H., Belloumi, S., Horchani-Naifer, K., Sriti Eljazi, J., Haoual Hamdi, S., Msaada, K., Labidi, J., Abderrabba, M., and Mediouni Ben Jemaa, J. 2022. Insecticidal effects of two Tunisian diatomaceous earth loaded with Thymus capitatus (L.) Hoffmans and Links as an ecofriendly approach for stored coleopteran pest control. International Journal of Environmental Health Research. 33(4): 1-15.
Barranco-Florido, E., Bustamante-Camilo, P., Mayorga-Reyes, L., González-Cervantes, R., Martínez-Cruz, P., and Azaola,
A. 2009. B-n-acetylglucosaminidase production by Lecanicillium (Verticillium) lecanii ATCC 26854 by solid-state fermentation utilizing shrimp shell. Interciencia, 34(5): 356- 360.
Berlanga-Padilla, A. M. and Hernández-Velázquez, V. H. 2002. Efecto de la temperatura sobre el crecimiento y la virulencia de Metarhizium anisopliae, M. a. Var. acridum y Beauveria bassiana en Schistocerca piceifrons piceifrons. Manejo Integrado de Plagas, 63(1): 51-55.
Castro, J. A., Castillo, F. A., and Torres, Y. S. 2022. Organic agriculture in mexico: A challenge for sustainability and its international commercialization. Revista Do CEDS, 2(11). available in: https://periodicos.undb.edu.br/index.php/ ceds/article/view/51
Colín-García, M., Heredia, A., and Dos Santos, C. 2013. Sílice de las algas diatomeas (Clase Bacillariophyceae) como material complejo y su importancia nanotecnológica. La Granja. Revista de Ciencias de la Vida. 17(1): 5-15.
Del Puerto, A. M., Suárez Tamayo, S., and Palacio Estrada, D. E. 2014. Efectos de los plaguicidas sobre el ambiente y la salud. Revista Cubana de Higiene y Epidemiología. 52(3): 372-387.
Korunic, Z. 1998. Diatomaceous earths, a group of natural insecticides. Journal of Stored Products Research. 34(2): 87-97.
Korunic, Z. 2013. Diatomaceous earths—Natural insecticides.
Pesticidii fitomedicina. 28(2): 77-95.
Liauw, C. M., Slate, A. J., Butler, J. A., Wilson-Nieuwenhuis, J. S. T., Deisenroth, T., Preuss, A., Verran, J., and Whitehead,
K. A. 2020. The effect of surface hydrophobicity on the attachment of fungal conidia to substrates of polyvinyl acetate and polyvinyl alcohol. Journal of Polymers and the Environment. 28(5): 1450-1464.
Litwin, A., Nowak, M., and Różalska, S. 2020. Entomopathogenic fungi: Unconventional applications. Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology. 19(1): 23-42.
Losic, D., and Korunic, Z. 2018. Diatomaceous earth, a natural insecticide for stored grain protection: Recent progress and perspectives. RSC Nanoscience and Nanotechnology. 44(1): 219-247.
Mujica, Y., Martínez, M. de los A., Alemán, J., and Ravelo, J. 2009. Fluctuación poblacional de plagas de la col (Brassicaoleracea) y otros enemigos naturales en dos agroecosistemas. Cultivos Tropicales. 30(4): 00-00.
Nattrass, C., Horwell, C., Damby, D., Kermanizadeh, A., Brown, D., and Stone, V. 2015. The global variability of diatomaceous earth toxicity: A physicochemical and in vitro investigation. Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology. 10(1): 1-23.
Nazzaro, F., Orlando, P., Fratianni, F., and Coppola, R. 2012. Microencapsulation in food science and biotechnology. Current Opinion in Biotechnology. 23(2): 182-186.
Ozdemir, I. O., Tuncer, C., Erper, I., and Kushiyev, R. 2020. Efficacy of the entomopathogenic fungi; Beauveria bassiana and Metarhizium anisopliae against the cowpea weevil, Callosobruchus maculatus F. (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae: Bruchinae). Egyptian Journal of Biological Pest Control. 30(24): 1-5
Pacheco, M. de L., Reséndiz, J. F., and Arriola, V. J. 2019. Organismos entomopatógenos como control biológico en los sectores agropecuario y forestal de México: Una revisión. Revista mexicana de ciencias forestales. 10(56): 4-32.
Reka, A. A., Pavlovski, B., Fazlija, E., Berisha, A., Pacarizi, M., Daghmehchi, M., Sacalis, C., Jovanovski, G., Makreski, P., and Oral, A. 2021. Diatomaceous earth: Characterization, thermal modification, and application. Open Chemistry. 19(1): 451-461.
SAS System Viewer software. 2008. Available in: https://sas- system.updatestar.com/es
Schwentesius, R., and Gómez, L. 2015. Organic agriculture in Mexico and its contributions to sustainable development.
20(1). Available in: https://www.researchgate.net/ publication/288503743_Organic_Agriculture_in_Mexico_ and_its_Contributions_to_Sustainable_Development
SIAP. 2019. Reporte Col (repollo) [SIACON]. Available in: https:// www.gob.mx/siap/documentos/siacon-ng-161430.
Vargas-Flores, M. E. 2003. Caracterización de tres cepas de Beauveria brongniartii (Saccardo) Petch y su virulencia en Phthorimaea sp. (Zeller) y Symmetrischema tangolias (Gyen). Doctorado en ciencias. Tesis. Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos.
Wakil, W., Schmitt, T., and Kavallieratos, N. 2021. Persistence and efficacy of enhanced diatomaceous earth, imidacloprid, and Beauveria bassiana against three coleopteran and one psocid stored-grain insects. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. 28: 23459-23472.
Wang, C., and Wang, S. 2017. Insect pathogenic fungi: Genomics, molecular interactions, and genetic improvements. Annual Review of Entomology. 62(1): 73-90.
Wenzel, I. M. W., Batista, A., Giordano, I. B., Denadae, B. E., Fernandes, J. B., and Forim, M. R. 2017. Compatibility of polymers to fungi Beauveria bassiana and Metarhizium anisopliae and their formulated products stability. Acta Scientiarum. Agronomy. 39(4): 457-464.
Willer, H. 2021. The world of organic agriculture. FAO. Available in: http://www.fao.org/family-farming/detail/es/c/1378841/ Zeni, V., Baliota, G. V., Benelli, G., Canale, A., and Athanassiou,
C. G. 2021. Diatomaceous earth for arthropod pest control: Back to the future. Molecules. 26(24): 7487